The Client He Couldn’t Afford to Keep

He was proud of this client, and he had earned the right to be. A national property management company — 180 commercial properties across three states, $1.4M of his $6.1M in annual revenue. Eighteen months to develop. The centerpiece of his commercial growth strategy.

“What’s your margin on the account?” I asked. “About the same as other commercial work,” he said. “Maybe a little lower, because of the volume discount we gave to win it.” “What volume discount?” “We bid 8% below market to win the initial contract. We’ve been renewing at that rate for three years.”

He had no job cost reports segmented by account. We built them. It took two weeks, and what came out of them changed how he understood his own business.

What the Account Actually Paid

With real labor burden, equipment depreciation, vehicle cost per job, and the compliance overhead this client’s reporting standards required, the flagship account produced $154,000 of gross profit on $1.4M — 11% gross margin. His other commercial work ran 41%. The compliance cost alone had never been priced: daily photo uploads to a proprietary portal, weekly written progress reports, 2–3 hours of PM administrative time per job — about $12,600 a year, invisible on the P&L. And the contract said Net 60 while payment actually ran 94 days. On $1.4M of revenue he was floating roughly $360,000 of this client’s receivables at any time; at his 8% line of credit, call it $28,800 a year for the privilege. All in, the account contributed about 8 cents of profit per dollar of revenue.

The Three Doors

Every owner in this position has the same three options: reprice, reduce, or exit. He chose the first door, and the conversation he had been dreading for three years turned out to be a negotiation, not a funeral. He won a 9% rate increase, which moved the account to 19% gross margin. He set a floor — declining jobs under $8,000 from this account — and redirected his commercial development toward fee-based direct relationships delivering 35%+ margins. The flagship is still a client today. It’s just no longer the centerpiece of the strategy, because he finally knows what it costs.

The Lesson I Take From This One

The accounts you believe are most important deserve the most scrutiny, because the assumptions that made them attractive may no longer be true. Review account-level profitability at least annually — semi-annually for your top five to ten clients. And know this going in: walking away from a below-cost relationship is a strategic decision, not a failure. The failure is renewing it for three years without ever running its numbers.

The full analysis — including how to build account-level profitability reporting from job cost data — is in The Profit Detective Files: The Commercial Company Bleeding Cash on Its Best Client.

Related reading

• The Commercial Restoration Company Bleeding Cash on Its Best Client
• What I Found in a $2.3M Alberta Restoration Company With No Cash
• The Mold Company That Was Busy and Broke

Mike McCabe is The Profit Detective — a 36-year restoration industry veteran who has conducted account-level profitability diagnostics for commercial restoration companies across North America.